ROI of AP Automation - a ROI Meeting takes place
Published: | Time to read: 7 minutes

The ROI of AP Automation – A Case Study

Matt Wald
Author:Matt Wald

This fictional case study chronicles EliteTech CFO Emily’s journey as she implements AP Automation to address their inefficient accounts payable process.

It explores the investment costs and the implementation strategy, followed by an analysis of the significant cost savings and efficiency gains. It concludes with a detailed assessment of the ROI, emphasizing the financial and operational benefits realized through this transformative decision.

The numbers in this article are based on industry benchmarks and real-life results.

The ROI of AP Automation – Problem Awareness

Emily is the CFO of a forward-thinking tech company. She faced a common yet significant challenge in her financial operations: inefficient manual invoice processing and paper invoices.

Emily knew this didn’t fit with their company’s tech image. The old way was taking too much time and creating massive overhead expenses.

Emily suspected that automation could make her AP process faster, more accurate, and save money. So, she investigated it.

Here you can learn everything about the AP Automation Best Practices!

Evaluating the Costs: The Decision to Automate

The decision to shift to automated invoice processing was not one Emily took lightly.

Known for her thorough approach, Emily began by evaluating the existing costs associated with the existing processes. This evaluation revealed not only the direct expenses, such as labor and material costs, but also the hidden costs – errors, delays, and missed opportunities for early payment discounts.

The results of her analysis shocked her. Each invoice cost the company $15 to $40 to process. With thousands of invoices processed each year, the cost of the existing system added up quickly.

Emily then started researching various AP automation solutions. She sought a system that not only reduced costs but also aligned with her existing technology. Her criteria included ease of integration, scalability, and the ability to provide real-time financial insights.

Emily meticulously analyzed the pricing models, including setup fees, monthly subscriptions, and any additional costs for customization or additional features. She compared these against the potential cost savings in labor, time, and improved accuracy.

But Emily also considered the strategic benefits of AP Automation – improved vendor relationships due to timely payments, enhanced compliance, and data security. These factors, while not directly quantifiable in monetary terms, were vital for long-term operational strategy.

Convinced by her findings, Emily prepared a comprehensive cost-benefit analysis, highlighting the long-term financial advantages of automating invoice processing. Her company soon embarked on a transformative journey to modernize its AP process, a decision rooted in meticulous financial evaluation and a clear vision for the future.

Use our savings calculator to see how much you could save

Implementation Phase: Challenges and Investments

Emily chose her AP automation solution carefully.

The primary requirement was integrating the new system with her existing financial software. The new solution had to seamlessly pass data back and forth with her accounting system. Her company also had migration to a different ERP in its 5-year technology roadmap, so Emily sought AP automation software that could integrate with multiple ERPs.

Training the staff was another critical investment. Emily understood that for the automation to be successful, the team needed to be proficient in using the new system. So, she sought AP automation with an intuitive interface that would make user adoption easier.

There were also unforeseen challenges. For instance, adapting to a new way of processing invoices required a cultural shift within the organization. Emily led this change by highlighting the long-term benefits of automation, fostering a culture of innovation and efficiency.

The investment during this phase was not just financial; it involved time, effort, and a commitment to change. However, Emily was confident that these investments would pay off. She kept a close eye on the implementation process, ensuring that any issues were promptly addressed and that the transition to automation was as smooth as possible.

With the successful implementation of a new AP automation system, her company was now poised to experience the tangible benefits of its investment.

Get a free consultation with an AP automation expert

Realizing the Savings: Post-Implementation Success

There are numerous benefits in using an AP Automation ROI calculator

The post-implementation phase was crucial in realizing the savings and efficiencies that had motivated the switch.

One of the most immediate benefits was a significant reduction in processing time for invoices. What used to take days, or sometimes weeks, was now being accomplished in a matter of hours. This efficiency not only sped up the AP process but also freed up staff to focus on more strategic tasks.

Another notable improvement was in the accuracy of invoice processing and AP workflows. The automated system virtually eliminated human errors, reducing the costs associated with corrections and adjustments and was a great help for AP teams. This improvement in accuracy also led to better vendor relationships, as payments were timely and consistent, avoiding late fees and fostering goodwill.

Emily also observed a reduction in operational costs. The automation minimized the need for paper-based processes, thus cutting down on printing, storage, and retrieval expenses. This not only saved money but also aligned with her company’s environmental sustainability goals.

The most compelling evidence of success, however, came from the financial analysis. Within months, Emily saw a noticeable decrease in overall AP costs.

The cost for each invoice went down from about $30 to $5.

Emily’s strategic foresight for benefits of AP Automation had paid off.

Calculating the ROI of AP Automation: A Comprehensive Analysis

Calculating the AP Automation ROI might be difficult

After the new system was in place, Emily shifted her focus to a comprehensive analysis of the return on investment (ROI). This final piece was critical in quantifying the success of her decision to implement AP automation.

To calculate the ROI, Emily consolidated all the financial gains from the automation. This included the savings from reduced processing times, lower operational costs, and minimized human error. She also factored in the indirect financial benefits, such as improved staff productivity, morale and enhanced vendor relationships.

On top, the lack of late payment fees also made a difference.

The lower cost per invoice and processing thousands each year meant saving about $250,000 annually.

The solution she implemented cost $50,000 for set-up and implementation and had an annual subscription fee of $40,000.

The savings were clear. Emily’s choice to switch to automation was a smart move.

And the ROI was equally clear: the five-year cost of her AP automation solution was $250,000 – the same amount that the old manual process cost in ONE YEAR.

Emily’s comprehensive analysis also included a qualitative assessment of the benefits. Employee satisfaction had increased due to less tedious work. And the company’s reputation as a technologically advanced and efficient organization was bolstered.

Get a free consultation with an AP automation expert today!

Conclusion: Make the Smart Move to AP Automation

In conclusion, the decision to switch to automated invoice processing is a game-changer.

By moving away from the old, manual method, you can address a major overhead expense that wastes time and money.

The change isn’t easy. It involves researching the right system, training staff, and adapting to a new way of doing things. But it pays off.

Once AP automation is up and running, the benefits are clear. Invoice processing becomes much faster. Mistakes are greatly reduced, and the team can focus on more important tasks.

Most importantly, financial analysis will reveal real savings.

This significant savings and ROI of AP automation make the decision not only wise but also very profitable for the company.

That’s the power of embracing technology to improve efficiency and save money.

Get a free consultation with an AP automation expert
What is AP Automation?

AP Automation, or Accounts Payable Automation, refers to the use of technology and software to streamline and automate the accounts payable processes within an organization. It includes tasks such as invoice processing, payment approvals, and supplier management.

Why should my company consider implementing AP Automation?

Implementing AP Automation can lead to several benefits, including improved efficiency, reduced manual errors, process invoices faster, enhanced visibility into financial data, and ultimately, cost savings. It can also free up your employees from routine tasks, allowing them to focus on more strategic activities.

What is the ROI of AP Automation?

The ROI (Return on Investment) of AP Automation refers to the financial benefits and cost savings realized after implementing an AP Automation solution. This can include reduced processing costs, early payment discounts, improved supplier relationships, and increased accuracy in financial reporting.

How can I calculate the ROI of AP Automation for my organization?

To calculate the AP Automation ROI, you can consider factors such as the cost of implementing the solution, the time saved on manual tasks (labor costs), reduction in error rates, and any additional revenue or discounts gained from improved payment processing. The formula for ROI is [(Net Benefits / Cost of Investment) x 100].

What are the typical cost elements associated with AP Automation?

Cost elements may include software licensing fees, implementation costs, training expenses, and ongoing support and maintenance fees. It’s important to factor in both initial and recurring costs when calculating ROI.

How long does it take to see a positive ROI with AP Automation?

The timeline for realizing a positive ROI can vary depending on the size of your organization, the complexity of your AP processes, and the efficiency gains achieved. Some organizations see a return on their investment within a few months, while others may take a year or more.

What are some key benefits that contribute to the AP Automation ROI?

Key benefits include reduced invoice processing time, prevent manual processes elimination of late payment penalties, increased early payment discounts, improved compliance with payment terms, reduced error rates, enhanced invoice data accuracy, and better cash flow management.

Are there any risks associated with AP Automation that could impact ROI?

While AP Automation offers significant benefits, there are potential risks such as implementation challenges, data security concerns, and resistance to change among employees. Proper planning and mitigation strategies can help minimize these risks.

Can AP Automation solutions integrate with our existing accounting software?

Yes, many AP Automation solutions are designed to integrate seamlessly with popular accounting software packages like Microsoft GP, Microsoft Dynamics BC and Sage Intacct.

Is AP Automation suitable for all types of businesses and industries?

AP Automation can benefit businesses of various sizes and across different industries. However, the specific benefits and ROI may vary based on your organization’s unique needs and processes. It’s essential to assess your requirements and select a solution that aligns with your goals.